Stucco vs Brick: Pros, Cons, & Costs
- srcustommasonry
- 4 days ago
- 4 min read
Choosing between stucco vs brick can feel like a big decision, especially when both are genuinely such great options. Stucco gives homes a clean, seamless look and handles heat really well, while brick offers classic durability and has that low-maintenance charm. If you're unsure which direction to go, keep reading, and we'll walk through the pros, cons, and costs of each so you can make the best choice for your specific home and lifestyle.
Stucco vs Brick Cost
Stucco usually costs around $6 to $10 per square foot, while brick often runs closer to $10 to $20 for the same home. Because stucco is typically the more affordable option upfront, its energy-saving benefits can make it an even stronger long-term value. The main thing to watch for is moisture. If stucco isn’t installed or maintained correctly, trapped moisture can lead to damage. Good drainage goes a long way, and fixing small cracks early helps prevent bigger issues. Repairs can also be pricey because a single damaged spot often requires resurfacing a larger area to keep everything looking smooth. Stucco has plenty of upsides, but it’s important to consider the need for expert installation and the potential for expensive repairs.
Stucco vs Brick Pricing
Brick often comes with a higher price tag and can easily cost more than stucco for the same home. Many homeowners feel the extra cost pays off because brick lasts a long time and is extremely low-maintenance. Stucco, on the other hand, is often chosen in warmer, drier climates because it handles heat well and provides a smooth, energy-efficient finish.
Pros and Cons of Stucco
Pros of Stucco
Great at handling heat and dry climates
Creates a smooth, seamless look
Can be textured or colored for different styles
Fire-resistant and energy-efficient
Typically more affordable than full brick
Low maintenance when installed correctly
Cons of Stucco
Not ideal for very wet or humid climates
Can crack if the foundation shifts
Repairs can be noticeable if not blended well
Installation quality matters a lot as poor work leads to long-term problems
Can absorb moisture if not sealed or maintained properly
Pros and Cons of Brick
Pros of Brick
Extremely durable and long-lasting
Low maintenance compared to many other siding types
Great insulation against heat and cold
Fire-resistant and weather-resistant
Classic look that boosts curb appeal
Holds up well in a wide range of climates
Cons of Brick
Higher upfront cost than many siding options
Limited color options without painting
Installation takes more time and skilled labor
Mortar joints may need repointing over time
Heavier material, so it isn’t always ideal for every home structure
Resale Value and Long-Term Investment
If you’re thinking in terms of resale value, both stucco and brick can give your home a solid boost, but they do it in different ways. Brick often stands out to buyers because of its reputation for lasting decades with very little upkeep. Many see brick as a premium exterior, which can help your home feel more sturdy and well-built. This perception alone can nudge resale value higher, especially in areas where brick homes are common and in high demand.
Stucco also performs well in the resale world, especially in areas where it fits the local style and climate. Buyers who prefer a clean, modern look often gravitate toward stucco because it creates a smooth, cohesive finish.
From an investment standpoint, brick generally requires less ongoing care, which keeps long-term expenses lower. Stucco may need more attention over the years, but when maintained well, it still offers strong value and a look that ages gracefully.
Weather Performance in Different Climates
Weather plays a huge role in how well brick or stucco holds up, and each material has conditions where it naturally performs better. Brick tends to work best in areas with cold winters because it handles freeze-thaw cycles with far fewer issues. When temperatures swing up and down, moisture inside certain materials can expand and contract, causing cracking or damage. Brick’s density and durability help it withstand those shifts. This is why you see it used so often in places like Utah, the Midwest, and the Northeast.
Stucco, on the other hand, thrives in warm, dry regions where humidity and heavy rainfall aren’t constantly causing challenges. It does especially well in the Southwest, think Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico, and parts of California, because the climate stays dry enough to avoid moisture problems. Stucco also handles heat extremely well, and its smooth finish can help keep homes cooler when temperatures spike.
Stucco vs Brick Conclusion
In the end, you can’t go wrong with either of these siding options. Consider what style best complements the look and feel you’re hoping to create while staying within the budget you’ve set. Think of it as matching the material to the kind of life your home will live.
If you decide brick is the better fit, and you’re in the SLC area, our team at S&R Masonry is here to help. We handle everything from full brick exteriors and accent walls to fireplaces, chimneys, walkways, and custom brick features. With years of experience and a commitment to quality craftsmanship, we make sure your project looks great and lasts.
Comments